The Rt Hon the Baroness Butler-Sloss GBE

First female Treasurer of the Inn and first female member of Court of Appeal

(née Havers, created Baroness Butler-Sloss of Marsh Green in 2006, b. 1933)

Admitted 1951, Called 1955, Treasurer 1998

Elizabeth Butler-Sloss was called to the Bar in 1955. In 1979 she was the fourth woman to be appointed a High Court judge, and in 1988 she became the first woman to be appointed a Lord Justice of Appeal. In 1999 she became the President of the Family Division of the High Court of Justice and consequently the highest-ranking female judge in the UK. During her judicial career she chaired the Cleveland child abuse enquiry (which led to the Children Act 1989) and was responsible for the ruling that the child killers of James Bulger should receive lifelong anonymity. She was created Baroness Butler-Sloss, a life peer, in 2006.

She was born Elizabeth Havers, daughter of the QC and High Court Judge Sir Cecil Havers. Her elder brother Robert also became a barrister, QC and eventually a life peer and Attorney General. She was educated at Wycombe Abbey School, then spent a year at the University of Lausanne before being admitted to The Inner Temple in 1951 without a university degree. In a later interview, she described her father’s attitude to her decision to become a barrister as:

extraordinarily modern: [he] said if my brother could do it, so indeed could I if I was clever enough.

When she was called to the Bar in 1955, women still made up only 3% of barristers. She remembers her chambers as a very accepting place for her as a woman. However, she did encounter prejudice elsewhere, notably in the person of a solicitor who, five years after her Call, refused her services in favour of a man who was still serving his pupillage, purely on the basis of her gender.

In 1958, Elizabeth married Joe Butler-Sloss, who was also a barrister. She had three children and continued to practise law in spite of the increasing challenge of balancing work and home life. When she was offered a job as a divorce registrar, her father told her it was a “backwater job” from which she could not expect promotion, but told her she owed it to her family to accept it as it would allow her to spend more time with her children. Against her expectations and those of her father, however, she was promoted to the High Court in 1979.

Butler-Sloss’s appointment as chair of the Cleveland Child Abuse Inquiry in 1987 made her much better known to the public. The Inquiry’s task was to investigate a steep and sudden rise in suspected sexual abuse cases in the Middlesbrough area. Over a five-month period, social services had removed 121 children from their homes on suspicion that they had been sexually abused. Butler-Sloss concluded in her report that the vast majority of the abuse accusations were false; 94 of the children were later returned to their homes. The results of the Inquiry were a major contributor to the passing of the Children Act 1989, which sought to rebalance the law in favour of the rights of children rather than parents or local authorities.

In 1988, Butler-Sloss was the first woman to be appointed to the Court of Appeal: her official title was Lord Justice Butler-Sloss, until the Master of the Rolls intervened to give official approval to the title of Lady Justice. When in 1999 she was made President of the High Court’s Family Division, she became (and remained until 2004) the highest-ranking woman in the judiciary.

Butler-Sloss’s career both in the Court of Appeal and in retirement has been a high-profile one. In 2001, she ruled that Jon Venables and Robert Thompson, the 10-year-old boys who murdered James Bulger, should be given lifelong anonymity. From 2004 to 2007 she chaired the inquests into the deaths of Diana, Princess of Wales and Dodi Fayed. Her position as head of the Family Division made her a frequent target for parents angered by court decisions over the custody of their children. She was chosen to lead the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse in 2014, but stepped down after only a few days to avoid accusations of a conflict of interest: her brother had been Attorney General when some of the alleged abuse took place.

She retired in 2005 as President of the Family Division of the High Court but has continued to be active in public life as a crossbencher in the House of Lords. She is currently Co-Chairman of All Party Parliamentary Group on Religion in the Media.